What Would Cinderella Do?

Same color – similar design – different brands.

Nine West Shock Mode Wedge – Macy’s $85

Alfani Bess Sling Wedges – Macy’s $69

I love both of these shoes but cannot decide which one to get.

The slingback design is slightly dressier. But I think I can wear them both with skirts, pants, dresses, to work, out and about, etc. I would wear the Nine West wedge with shorts but I don’t quite know if I would wear the slingbacks with shorts.

Which would you pick?